And therein lies the problem with the Idaho Code. It’s also the problem with every other state’s laws. If everyone followed the law, everything would go fine. But people don’t.
I don’t.
I remember when I was a little kid, riding around the neighborhood on my red Huffy BMX with white, plastic wheel covers. I rode that thing from jump to jump all day during the summer. My mom used to tell me that I was supposed to ride on the sidewalk, then get off my bike and walk it across the street, but I didn’t care. I rode in the street, down alleys, hopped curbs from the sidewalk to the street, rode on whichever side of the street pleased me. The only rules for me were the limits of my Huffy’s white tires.
But I’m not a kid anymore. I realize that there are repercussions for my actions. And I understand that there are other people in the world other than me who are just as human as I am and have just as much right to the road.
Adult or child, riding a bike is still just as good an idea now as it ever was. Anyone can see that more and more people are taking to the streets on bicycles these days and this is a trend that’s unlikely to reverse given still-very-high gas prices, the increasing use of buzzwords like “green” and “sustainable” and America’s giant shift to the left this election. Bikes are hot right now. And they will get hotter. America will be increasingly confronted with the question of how to manage all these cyclists on the roads.
For my part, I’ve just been trying not to make things any worse. I still can’t force myself to stop at stop signs, but now I slow down and make damn sure that the coast is clear before I continue. I still run red lights if there’s no one around to see me, but I try not to make a show of it. I ride by the Idaho Code, essentially – and it works extremely well. I can still ride fast. I can still ride a purple track bike with no brakes and try to look like a badass. I just have to be considerate. And realize that people in cars are people too. They may not have figured out that they should be riding a bike and that they probably don’t have any good excuse to drive everywhere yet, but I’m not going to convince them by being a jackass. They have their reasons for driving and they deserve the same respect that anyone else on the road deserves.
As for the Idaho Code, I don’t think that legislators are ready for it yet. It sounds sort of extreme at this point. But as “traffic” becomes more and more comprised of bicycles, states will be increasingly compelled to reconsider their “traffic laws.”
Personally, I’m convinced. I’ve run 5,840 stop signs in the last year and I haven’t died or gotten a ticket once. If anything, riding by Idaho’s code has made me safer and more responsible. The law might tell me that I should behave like a car, but my common sense tells me that I when I pull up to an intersection in the middle of the night and no one is around, I might as well just roll right on through.
Tuesday, November 11, 2008
Stop Signs Part 7
Meanwhile, cyclists in Idaho seem comfortable enough with their Code.
“It’s been the same ever since I moved here,” said Dave Seasons, manager of Ken’s Bicycles in Boise. “Since at least ’93. And I’ve never had an instance with traffic.”
Idaho Code 49-746, which permitted cyclists to run stop signs, passed in 1982. The red light law went into effect in 2005.
“In retrospect the stop sign law is not a bad law,” Mark McNeese, State Bicycle and Pedestrian Coordinator of the Idaho Transportation Department said. “It certainly makes riding a bike more enjoyable. Overcoming inertia takes a lot of energy from a cyclist.”
The Idaho Code isn’t perfect. Both Seasons and McNeese said that they get the impression that most drivers have no idea that cyclists are allowed to run stop signs and red lights. This might create resentment among drivers and a sense that cyclists are reckless, but McNeese doesn't think it makes cycling any more dangerous.
"I can assure you that cyclists understand very well the repercussions of motor-vehicle/bicycle collisions and are not 'blatantly' inviting disaster."
George Knight, a cycling advocate and philosophy professor at Boise State University (agrees that cyclists can make their own decisions.)
"In a way it seems kind of goofy to not give [cyclists] exceptions to laws not created for [them]. At signalized intersections, I'd rather just get the heck out of there. The whole thing is just putting MY safety in MY hands."
But Knight acknowledges that cyclists take liberties with Idaho's Code.
"You do see people just blasting through. Then someone 200 yards away sees that and draws whatever conclusions they draw. And a lot of time they think that cyclists don't stop at stop signs at all."
Then drivers get mad. Or they get skittish and sit at stop signs waiting for cyclists to blast through and nobody goes anywhere. Or cyclists start to get used to cars letting them go ahead and become emboldened to the point of not stopping at intersections with or without traffic until one day someone runs a stop sign and gets run over.
"If people always acted according to the letter of the law," Knight said, "everything would go fine..."
“It’s been the same ever since I moved here,” said Dave Seasons, manager of Ken’s Bicycles in Boise. “Since at least ’93. And I’ve never had an instance with traffic.”
Idaho Code 49-746, which permitted cyclists to run stop signs, passed in 1982. The red light law went into effect in 2005.
“In retrospect the stop sign law is not a bad law,” Mark McNeese, State Bicycle and Pedestrian Coordinator of the Idaho Transportation Department said. “It certainly makes riding a bike more enjoyable. Overcoming inertia takes a lot of energy from a cyclist.”
The Idaho Code isn’t perfect. Both Seasons and McNeese said that they get the impression that most drivers have no idea that cyclists are allowed to run stop signs and red lights. This might create resentment among drivers and a sense that cyclists are reckless, but McNeese doesn't think it makes cycling any more dangerous.
"I can assure you that cyclists understand very well the repercussions of motor-vehicle/bicycle collisions and are not 'blatantly' inviting disaster."
George Knight, a cycling advocate and philosophy professor at Boise State University (agrees that cyclists can make their own decisions.)
"In a way it seems kind of goofy to not give [cyclists] exceptions to laws not created for [them]. At signalized intersections, I'd rather just get the heck out of there. The whole thing is just putting MY safety in MY hands."
But Knight acknowledges that cyclists take liberties with Idaho's Code.
"You do see people just blasting through. Then someone 200 yards away sees that and draws whatever conclusions they draw. And a lot of time they think that cyclists don't stop at stop signs at all."
Then drivers get mad. Or they get skittish and sit at stop signs waiting for cyclists to blast through and nobody goes anywhere. Or cyclists start to get used to cars letting them go ahead and become emboldened to the point of not stopping at intersections with or without traffic until one day someone runs a stop sign and gets run over.
"If people always acted according to the letter of the law," Knight said, "everything would go fine..."
Monday, November 10, 2008
Stop Sign Part 6
The League of American Bicyclists, one of the largest nonprofit cycling advocacy and education groups in the nation, is conflicted about the Idaho Code.
“We don’t have a formal position on it,” Executive Director Andy Clarke said. “And recent discussions about coming up with one identified a wide divergence of views from the political to the philosophical that seem tough to reconcile at the moment.”
Education Director Preston Tyree heads up a team of 20 “coaches” who instruct the League instructors across the country. When the League tried to develop a position on the Idaho Code, they went to the coaches for input.
“Out of those 20,” Tyree said, “it came down pretty much even on ‘it’s a great idea’/’it’s a terrible idea.’”
Tyree has his own take on the Code.
"Cyclists have the same rights and should act and be treated as vehicles. If we somehow make them different from cars, we're gonna have a problem.”
Separate laws for cyclists would probably aggravate some drivers, Tryee said, which might very well create the type of tension that could lead to more dangerous conditions for cyclists.
Well, they can suck it up, one might say, cyclists are different from cars. They’re certainly less dangerous. Why not just let them do what they do anyway?
“While bicyclists and drivers of motor vehicles have different equipment,” Tyree said, “they are on the same roads and should act the same to be predictable.”
Cyclists fall under the same traffic laws in every state other than Idaho for a reason, Tyree said. “It’s the safest way to operate.”
“You can quote me as saying this: I’m very uncomfortable with the Idaho law.”
“We don’t have a formal position on it,” Executive Director Andy Clarke said. “And recent discussions about coming up with one identified a wide divergence of views from the political to the philosophical that seem tough to reconcile at the moment.”
Education Director Preston Tyree heads up a team of 20 “coaches” who instruct the League instructors across the country. When the League tried to develop a position on the Idaho Code, they went to the coaches for input.
“Out of those 20,” Tyree said, “it came down pretty much even on ‘it’s a great idea’/’it’s a terrible idea.’”
Tyree has his own take on the Code.
"Cyclists have the same rights and should act and be treated as vehicles. If we somehow make them different from cars, we're gonna have a problem.”
Separate laws for cyclists would probably aggravate some drivers, Tryee said, which might very well create the type of tension that could lead to more dangerous conditions for cyclists.
Well, they can suck it up, one might say, cyclists are different from cars. They’re certainly less dangerous. Why not just let them do what they do anyway?
“While bicyclists and drivers of motor vehicles have different equipment,” Tyree said, “they are on the same roads and should act the same to be predictable.”
Cyclists fall under the same traffic laws in every state other than Idaho for a reason, Tyree said. “It’s the safest way to operate.”
“You can quote me as saying this: I’m very uncomfortable with the Idaho law.”
Stop Signs Part 5
The day after that, I met with Fort Collins Bike Director Dave “DK” Kemp to get his take on the Idaho Code.
“Did you hear about the latest cycling accident?” he asked me.
“No. What happened?”
Two days before, on the same day that I’d been stopping at stop signs for recreation, cyclist Thomas Baxendale ran a stop sign, crossing Stuart on Remington. Darrell Keller - maybe because he was driving into the sun, maybe because the stop sign was slightly obscured by a tree - ran his stop sign on Stuart at the exact same time. Baxendale was hit by Keller’s Ford Expedition and dragged 100 feet down Stuart before Keller could stop. He was in the hospital in serious condition, miraculously alive, when I heard about it.
This was just an example of the danger of the Idaho Code, DK said.
“There are all of these factors, you know. Maybe someone's drunk. Maybe someone's unaware or oblivious because they've got something on their mind. There are all these variables, then you bring it all together and everyone’s moving.”
Thomas Baxendale is 26 years old, my age. And I’d run the same stop sign that Baxendale ran more than once. The view to the left is obscured by a tree. But it’s a four way stop. If there’s a car coming, they’ll stop.
I’m sure that Darrell Keller didn’t mean to run that stop sign. But this illustrates DK’s point. A cyclist can’t always count on a driver to do what he’s supposed to do. Riding a bike on city streets can be dangerous.
“Did you hear about the latest cycling accident?” he asked me.
“No. What happened?”
Two days before, on the same day that I’d been stopping at stop signs for recreation, cyclist Thomas Baxendale ran a stop sign, crossing Stuart on Remington. Darrell Keller - maybe because he was driving into the sun, maybe because the stop sign was slightly obscured by a tree - ran his stop sign on Stuart at the exact same time. Baxendale was hit by Keller’s Ford Expedition and dragged 100 feet down Stuart before Keller could stop. He was in the hospital in serious condition, miraculously alive, when I heard about it.
This was just an example of the danger of the Idaho Code, DK said.
“There are all of these factors, you know. Maybe someone's drunk. Maybe someone's unaware or oblivious because they've got something on their mind. There are all these variables, then you bring it all together and everyone’s moving.”
Thomas Baxendale is 26 years old, my age. And I’d run the same stop sign that Baxendale ran more than once. The view to the left is obscured by a tree. But it’s a four way stop. If there’s a car coming, they’ll stop.
I’m sure that Darrell Keller didn’t mean to run that stop sign. But this illustrates DK’s point. A cyclist can’t always count on a driver to do what he’s supposed to do. Riding a bike on city streets can be dangerous.
Stop Signs Part 4
I still think that the Idaho Code makes sense, though. And where I think the Code might be a lot more applicable is the town I live in: Fort Collins, Colorado.
Fort Collins is a smallish college town with bike lanes on practically every street. It's flat. On the side streets of Old Town there are almost as many cyclists as cars. And normally I can run practically every stop sign without worrying about imminent death. So why stop?
Seriously. Why stop? I couldn’t really say. So, as a sort of fact-finding mission, I decided to ride according to the letter of the current law for a day in Fort Collins. I’d signal all turns, fully stop at all stop signs, wait at all red lights, ride on the right side of the road, not flip people off, not spit on cars that turn into the bike lane and almost kill me, not cut corners or take weird, questionably-legal shortcuts through sidewalks and parking lots. Generally, I’d be a courteous, responsible, law-abiding cyclist.
I hopped on my bike on a weekday morning, took off East from my house down Magnolia as I do every morning and ran the first three stop signs I encountered, forgetting my vow. Shit. Force of habit.
Once I got the hang of it, obeying the law was easy, if a little unnatural. I waited at a red light at Mulberry and Remington and watched a guy across the street pull up, look both ways and ride across the empty street toward me. I felt a little uneasy when another cyclist came up behind me, wondering, I imagined, why the hell I was still sitting there. The light mercifully turned green and I accelerated away quickly to compensate.
To sensationalize my frustration, I rode down West Myrtle with its quiet blocks punctuated by stop signs – stop signs there more because of orthodoxy than anything else, as far as I could tell. It was sort of pleasant riding this way, to be honest. I soon stopped bothering to accelerate my single 46x16 gear up to spinning pace and instead just lazily turned the pedals down the block, stopped at the end, put my foot down, looked both ways and rolled down the next stretch, smiling at the trees.
I stopped at 22 stop signs the day of my experiment. I could have run 16 of them under Idaho’s Code while 6 were contested and I would have had to stop anyway. I could have run two of the seven red lights that I stopped at.
Normally I would have run all of the uncontested stop signs and red lights. And I don’t have a car so I ride every day. Let’s say that this is an average day. That means that I probably run 5,840 stop signs and 730 red lights in Fort Collins every year – all of them totally legal under Idaho’s code. This may not be completely accurate, but the bottom line is that even though it’s illegal, I run a lot of stop signs and red lights. And I’m not alone.
I sat at the intersection of Laurel and Peterson, a four-way stop with good visibility for an hour between 4:30 and 5:30 pm the next day to see what other cyclists do at stop signs in Fort Collins. 42 cyclists came through the intersection while I was watching. Only two stopped. They both had contested intersections, so they would have had to stop in Idaho anyway. Many of the other cyclists rode through contested intersections without stopping, usually by timing their entry and riding through when they had a space, just like the riders in San Francisco, just like me. But most of the cyclists had uncontested intersections and they just rolled through without a care. A roadie in spandex coasted up, looking back and forth, and then pushed through with a couple of stout strokes. A studious-looking foreign exchange student continued her slow pace, looking left and right the entire way through. A gentleman wearing a tie and a helmet rode through upright and fearless on his comfort bike. An older Cheech Marin lookalike cruised through on a low rider bike with flames. An entire neighborhood glided home, united only by their aloof dismissal of the red signs that tell cars to stop.
Fort Collins is a smallish college town with bike lanes on practically every street. It's flat. On the side streets of Old Town there are almost as many cyclists as cars. And normally I can run practically every stop sign without worrying about imminent death. So why stop?
Seriously. Why stop? I couldn’t really say. So, as a sort of fact-finding mission, I decided to ride according to the letter of the current law for a day in Fort Collins. I’d signal all turns, fully stop at all stop signs, wait at all red lights, ride on the right side of the road, not flip people off, not spit on cars that turn into the bike lane and almost kill me, not cut corners or take weird, questionably-legal shortcuts through sidewalks and parking lots. Generally, I’d be a courteous, responsible, law-abiding cyclist.
I hopped on my bike on a weekday morning, took off East from my house down Magnolia as I do every morning and ran the first three stop signs I encountered, forgetting my vow. Shit. Force of habit.
Once I got the hang of it, obeying the law was easy, if a little unnatural. I waited at a red light at Mulberry and Remington and watched a guy across the street pull up, look both ways and ride across the empty street toward me. I felt a little uneasy when another cyclist came up behind me, wondering, I imagined, why the hell I was still sitting there. The light mercifully turned green and I accelerated away quickly to compensate.
To sensationalize my frustration, I rode down West Myrtle with its quiet blocks punctuated by stop signs – stop signs there more because of orthodoxy than anything else, as far as I could tell. It was sort of pleasant riding this way, to be honest. I soon stopped bothering to accelerate my single 46x16 gear up to spinning pace and instead just lazily turned the pedals down the block, stopped at the end, put my foot down, looked both ways and rolled down the next stretch, smiling at the trees.
I stopped at 22 stop signs the day of my experiment. I could have run 16 of them under Idaho’s Code while 6 were contested and I would have had to stop anyway. I could have run two of the seven red lights that I stopped at.
Normally I would have run all of the uncontested stop signs and red lights. And I don’t have a car so I ride every day. Let’s say that this is an average day. That means that I probably run 5,840 stop signs and 730 red lights in Fort Collins every year – all of them totally legal under Idaho’s code. This may not be completely accurate, but the bottom line is that even though it’s illegal, I run a lot of stop signs and red lights. And I’m not alone.
I sat at the intersection of Laurel and Peterson, a four-way stop with good visibility for an hour between 4:30 and 5:30 pm the next day to see what other cyclists do at stop signs in Fort Collins. 42 cyclists came through the intersection while I was watching. Only two stopped. They both had contested intersections, so they would have had to stop in Idaho anyway. Many of the other cyclists rode through contested intersections without stopping, usually by timing their entry and riding through when they had a space, just like the riders in San Francisco, just like me. But most of the cyclists had uncontested intersections and they just rolled through without a care. A roadie in spandex coasted up, looking back and forth, and then pushed through with a couple of stout strokes. A studious-looking foreign exchange student continued her slow pace, looking left and right the entire way through. A gentleman wearing a tie and a helmet rode through upright and fearless on his comfort bike. An older Cheech Marin lookalike cruised through on a low rider bike with flames. An entire neighborhood glided home, united only by their aloof dismissal of the red signs that tell cars to stop.
Sunday, November 9, 2008
Stop Signs Part 3
I'm exaggerating San Francisco's freneticness. I got around ok and more or less observed the Idaho Code for a day or so. To tell you the truth, it went fairly well. When I was following the code, I was one of the safer and more cordial cyclists on the road. But with so much traffic, my chances of pulling a fast one at an intersection in San Francisco were slimmer than I'd have liked.
Stop Signs continued
I heard about Idaho's code before a recent trip to San Francisco, where the Bay Area Metropolitan Transportation Commission is considering similar laws for California. So I thought I'd test "the code" in action. I'd ride around San Francisco operating as if stop signs were yield signs and red lights were stop signs. If I could make it out without getting killed or pulled over, I figured, then Idaho's Code would be proven right. Plus, to be honest, I'll pretty much take any opportunity I can concoct to break the law in the name of "research."
There are a lot of stop signs in San Francisco. The trouble was finding stop signs that I could run according to Idaho's Code. I set out from the Panhandle toward the Marina on my friend Brandon's bling Cyclops track bike that not only doesn't have brakes but isn't even drilled for brakes. I'm used to riding a brakeless fixed gear bike, but the combination of hilly terrain and an unfamiliar handlebar setup had me hoping I wouldn't have to stop very often. But the first stop sign I came to had a car approaching so I hopped the back wheel a few times and hauled the thing to a stop with my legs. I waited my turn and continued to the next stop sign where the EXACT same thing happened. I lucked out at a lot of stop signs, looked both ways and breezed through, but by the time I got to Japantown and its heavier traffic and stop lights, I was getting closer and closer to abandoning the whole experiment. Every red light I came to there was traffic. There was NEVER a chance to run one. I quickly started renegotiating the particulars of Idaho's Code with myself.
"Well, I guess I don't really have to wait until there's no traffic. I just have to yield the right of way." Or, "OK, well, yeah, there's a car coming to this stop sign. But if I speed up and beat him through, I'm not putting anyone out."
I started darting across heavily trafficked streets whenever there was a gap. I started edging my way into intersections to get cars to hesitate so I could cut ahead of them. Mostly though, I just sat at red lights and waited - because I had to. There were so many cars in San Francisco during the daytime that Idaho's Code was usually mute. Either wait at a red light or die.
Tuesday, November 4, 2008
Should Cyclists Be Able To Run Red Lights and Stop Signs?
I don't stop at stop signs on my bike. I ride up to them, slow down, look both ways to make sure nobody's coming, then I hit the gas. Sometimes there are cars coming and I time it from a few hundred feet out so that I can blast the intersection before or after or between them. Sometimes I slow down and track stand when there's a line, and wait my turn - but I'll be damned if I put my foot down. At night when I can see the cars by thier headlights, I don't slow down at all. I ride full speed at the intersection on the left side of the road, then I cut sharply right going in so that if there IS a car coming, I can swerve right onto the street I'm crossing. Then I lean hard left and S-curve my way through the intersection, laughing at the night and trying not to lean so far that I clip my pedal on the street on my foxed gear.
I know I'm an asshole. I'm not helping "the cause" by pissing off drivers and endangering myself. But I just don;t see why I should stop. Nobody stops on a bike. I have perfect 360-degree visibility. I'm incredibly maneuverable. I don't move as fast as cars. And, most importantly, if I fuck up, I can't kill anyone but myself. Honestly, it seems like cyclists should have some special legal distinction from cars that allows them to run stop signs as long as they slow down and look both ways first.
As it turns out, just such a law does exist - in Idaho. Title 49-720, section 1, of the Idaho code states that a cyclist approaching a stop sign must slow down and yield the right of way to any traffic. But, in the event that a road is clear, the cyclist "may cautiously make a turn or proceed through the intersection without stopping." And it goes further in section 2 to add that a cyclist, after stopping at a red light and yielding the right of way to any traffic, "may proceed through the steady red light with caution."
So cyclists can run stop signs - as long as they're careful. And they can even run red lights as long as the coast is clear. Fantastic! It seemed like a no-brainer. But, I was to later find out, maybe there's a reason for all these lame-ass laws in every other state.
Wld u cntnue rdg?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)